Deep SHT · Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)
The Inside Llewyn Davis Ending Explained: The Loop, the Alley, and Bob Dylan
It ends where it began, and the second time through you know what he did.
The last song
“Fare Thee Well,” sung alone
The next act
A kid in a cap, singing “Farewell”
The last word
Au revoir
2
Times we see the Gaslight set and the alley
1
Song added the second time
0
Lines Llewyn speaks to the Dylan figure
6 min
From Ulysses coming home to the cab pulling away
The question
Is the ending of Inside Llewyn Davis the beginning?
Yes. The Inside Llewyn Davis ending is the opening: the Gaslight set that starts the film and the beating in the alley that follows it are the same events that close the film. Pappi says the same lines, the man in the suit throws the same punches, and Llewyn ends up in the same slush. The Inside Llewyn Davis ending, explained in one line, is the same night with the context restored. What the Coens withhold the first time is context; what they add the second time is everything the week has taught you: who the man in the suit is, what Llewyn shouted, what the song he sings alone used to be, and who the kid taking the stage behind him is about to become.
An Odyssey that goes nowhere
Ethan Coen gave the shape its best one-line description at the film’s New York Film Festival press conference: an Odyssey in which the main character doesn’t go anywhere. The structure isn’t a twist; rather, it’s the argument. A week of the hardest choices Llewyn will ever make lands him on the same stool, singing the same song, to the same room, and the film wants you to feel both halves of that at once: nothing has changed, and you now understand why.
What this piece covers
This is the long version of the Inside Llewyn Davis ending section on our Inside Llewyn Davis hub. It lays the two Gaslight nights side by side, explains why the beating is the film’s best joke, settles the Bob Dylan question, reads the solo “Fare Thee Well,” and ends with what au revoir is doing. The cat piece covers Ulysses coming home; this one covers the man who doesn’t.

The two nights
Same night, twice: what the opening leaves out
Watch the two sequences back to back, and the differences are small, deliberate, and all in one direction. The opening gives you “Hang Me, Oh Hang Me,” Llewyn’s sign-off about folk songs, a short exchange with Pappi, and the alley. Altogether it runs about five minutes. The ending joins the same set in the last verses of “Hang Me” and then gives you the pieces the opening elided, and it runs about six.
The set is longer
In the opening, Llewyn finishes “Hang Me,” says you’ve probably heard that one before, and walks off. In the ending, the film picks him up in the final verses of “Hang Me”; he says the same line, and then adds: all right, one more before I go. The one more, of course, is “Fare Thee Well,” the song he recorded with Mike Timlin, sung without Mike for the first time. Pappi’s remark that he and Mikey used to do that song lands on “Hang Me” the first time and on “Fare Thee Well” the second, and it means something different each time.
The exchange is shorter
Opening: Pappi tells him he was some mess last night, Llewyn says he’s an asshole, and Pappi says he doesn’t give a shit, it’s just music, your friend is out back. Ending: the same beats, but minus the line about music. The two scenes are different takes, not one scene replayed, and the Coens have said they shot the opening hand-held so that the moment would feel right when the film came back to it. Oscar Isaac described the result to an interviewer as a Möbius strip: the same night, with and without Dylan.
The alley has a reason
In the opening the man in the suit says Llewyn had to open his big mouth, that he yelled his crap from the audience last night, and that he and his wife are leaving this cesspool. The first time, admittedly, that’s all noise; we have no idea what he’s talking about. The second time he adds one line the opening didn’t have: my wife up there trying to sing. By then, however, we’ve watched Llewyn heckle Elizabeth Hobby from Elinora, Arkansas, off the Gaslight stage, and the line closes the case.
And someone takes the stage
Finally, the biggest addition isn’t a line. As Llewyn walks off, a young man in a cap with a harmonica rack sits down on the stool behind him, and by the time the first punch lands we can hear him through the wall, singing “Farewell.” The opening never shows the stage after Llewyn leaves it. By contrast, the ending can’t stop looking at it.
The lyric sheet
The loop as a folk song
Oscar Isaac described the structure on the Criterion making-of as a folk song: a first verse tells you about an incident, the later verses take you through the story, and by the last verse you’re back where you began but you know a lot more. Set the two nights out as verses and that’s exactly what the Inside Llewyn Davis ending gives you. Same chorus both times, naturally.
0:25 to 5:40
Verse one: the opening
- “Hang Me, Oh Hang Me,” from the first line to the last.
- You’ve probably heard that one before.
- Pappi: you and Mikey used to do that song. Some mess last night. It’s just music.
- Your friend is out back. Guy in a suit.
- Funny boy. Had to open your big mouth. We’re leaving this cesspool.
- Llewyn in the slush. Cut to a ceiling he doesn’t recognize.
If it was never new and it never gets old, it’s a folk song.
1:33 to 1:39
Verse two: the ending
- “Hang Me,” joined in its last verses.
- You’ve probably heard that one before. All right, one more before I go.
- “Fare Thee Well,” alone, with the harmony part left empty.
- Pappi: you and Mikey used to do that song. Some mess last night.
- A kid in a cap with a harmonica rack sits down on the stool.
- Funny boy. Had to open your big mouth. My wife up there trying to sing.
- Llewyn in the slush. Through the wall, “Farewell.” A cab. Two fingers. Au revoir.
If it was never new and it never gets old, it’s a folk song.
In short, every line in verse two that isn’t in verse one is the week’s work. The empty harmony is Mike; the kid on the stool is the future; the wife up there trying to sing is the night before. And the chorus, which sounded like wit the first time, is the film’s verdict on its hero the second: never new, never old, and going around again.
Same night. Same song. You know more.
The loop, in the order the film plays it
The joke
Why the beating is funny
Joel Coen has said the whole film started with a single image: a folk singer beaten up in an alley behind Gerde’s Folk City, and the question of why anyone would beat up a folk singer. Eventually, the answer the finished film gives is a working man from Arkansas whose wife had her first New York show, and a drunk in the audience asking where her corncob pipe was and whether she was wearing gingham panties, then screaming that he hates folk music and that the show is four micks and Grandma Moses.
The man in the suit who delivers the Inside Llewyn Davis ending is the one actual folk in a film about folk music. He took his crying wife home, then came back the next night to settle it. On the Criterion commentary one of the critics puts the joke in a sentence: authenticity kicks the shit out of the singer. Llewyn’s entire creed is that the old, anonymous, unvarnished thing is the real thing, and when the real thing shows up, it has a suit on and it wants to know what he does for a living.
What the draft had, and the film cut
The undated draft of the screenplay in our files gives the husband one more line in the alley: there was a record man in the audience that night. In the draft, Llewyn didn’t just humiliate a stranger’s wife; he wrecked her shot at a deal. The film drops it, and indeed the cut is a good one. The record man would have made the beating about business. Without him, instead, it’s about a man whose wife cried, which is the one kind of grievance Llewyn can’t argue his way out of.
The draft also has the beating end with the man calling the Gaslight a cesspool and telling Llewyn he can have it. That line, however, survives. It’s the film’s most accurate review of the scene, delivered by someone leaving it, and it’s the last thing anyone says to Llewyn before he says au revoir.
My wife up there trying to sing.
The man in the suit, the second time through
The next act
Is that Bob Dylan at the end of Inside Llewyn Davis?
Yes, in everything but the credits. The draft script names him outright: as the kicking subsides, we hear the performer inside the club, and it is Bob Dylan. The film, however, is coyer: the kid in the cap is never named, Llewyn never looks at him, and the song is a real Dylan recording of “Farewell,” a previously unreleased studio take that the Coens were allowed to use and that plays on the soundtrack as if it were live. On the page the kid sang “I Was Young When I Left Home”; the film swapped it for “Farewell,” which, as the Criterion commentary points out, Dylan built on “The Leaving of Liverpool,” a song Liam Clancy may have taught him at the White Horse.
What the song is doing
Hajdu’s reading on the commentary is the one worth carrying. Everything Llewyn sings, after all, is interpretation: old songs, arranged in the mode of Dave Van Ronk, drawn from the Lomax recordings and the Child ballads. “Farewell,” by contrast, is an original. It’s a kid writing from his own experience in his own voice, and the film puts him on the stool thirty seconds after Llewyn leaves it. The shift from interpreting the past to expressing a self is the thing that is about to make folk music a business, and Llewyn walks past it on his way to get punched.
That is why the Dylan scene in the Inside Llewyn Davis ending is for the audience and not for him. After all, we know what the kid becomes. Llewyn hears a few bars through a wall. The Coens never let the two of them share a frame, and they don’t need to. The point, then, isn’t that Llewyn missed Dylan. It’s that he was there, on the right night, in the right room, a week too early and a partner short.
What it does to Grossman
Bud Grossman’s verdict in Chicago, that he doesn’t see a lot of money here, is accurate on the day he gives it. Still, the real Albert Grossman went on to manage Dylan, and the kid on the stool is the moment his verdict starts to expire. The film lets you hold both facts: Grossman was right about Llewyn, and the world was about to change its mind about the whole scene. Llewyn is standing in the one week where the old answer is still true.

The song
“Fare Thee Well,” sung alone
The one song the Inside Llewyn Davis ending adds is the one the film has been withholding. “Fare Thee Well,” also known as “Dink’s Song,” was the Timlin and Davis record. We hear the duet version early, over the credits sequence with the cat, with Mike’s harmony on it. At the Gorfeins’ dinner Llewyn starts it and Lillian takes Mike’s part, and he stops the song to tear into her. Consequently, by the last night he has never finished it alone.
So when he says one more before I go and starts the song, the silence where the harmony should be is the point of the performance. Oscar Isaac has said the solo “Fare Thee Well” on the last night wasn’t in the script. On screen it plays as the goodbye to Mike that Llewyn has refused to say all week, and the lyric does the rest: if I had wings like Noah’s dove, I’d fly up the river to the one I love. The river is the Hudson. The one he loves jumped into it from the George Washington Bridge.
What changes, and what doesn’t
It would be a different Inside Llewyn Davis ending if the song fixed anything. It doesn’t. He finishes, Pappi sends him out back, and the week ends on the ground as before. What the song changes, instead, is you. The first time you saw the alley you watched a man take a beating. The second time you watch a man who has just sung his dead partner’s song alone for the first time take the same beating, and the Coens hold the shot a little longer, because now it costs something.
Read: every song in Inside Llewyn Davis and what it says about Llewyn
The build
How the Coens built the loop
The Inside Llewyn Davis ending was there from the start. Asked by Elvis Mitchell in a stage Q&A whether the structure came early, Ethan Coen described the initial idea as the beginning cycling around to the end, a parable, a big circle. At the New York Film Festival press conference the brothers said they shot the opening hand-held so that it would feel right when it came back around. T Bone Burnett and Isaac, talking to Indiewire, accepted the Möbius strip description: an opening without Dylan, a loop, and an ending with him.
The undated draft of the screenplay confirms the shape on the page. Its first pages open on the Gaslight set and the alley. Its last pages repeat the alley almost word for word, down to the two-finger salute and the line au revoir. Meanwhile, the things that changed between draft and film all tightened the loop rather than loosening it: the Dylan song swapped for an original, the record man cut from the husband’s speech, the solo “Fare Thee Well” added to the set.
The Odyssey that stays home
Kent Jones, in his Criterion essay, reads the film as a parody of the hero’s journey, with the least likely questing hero in American movies. The cat is named Ulysses and makes the real journey home. Llewyn makes the longest trip in the film, through Chicago and back, and ends on the same stool. Our cat piece runs the Homer parallels scene by scene. For the ending, though, the parallel that matters is Jean’s. In Washington Square, early in the week, she tells him the same things keep happening to him because he wants them to. The loop is the film agreeing with her.
Why the structure is the argument
A conventional ending would resolve the Chicago trip: a deal, a refusal, a change of heart. Instead, the Coens resolve nothing and repeat everything, and the repetition is the resolution. The hub lays out the six ways forward the week offers Llewyn and the six answers he gives. This ending is what those answers add up to. He isn’t punished for them, exactly. He simply gets the week again.

The last word
Au revoir: what happens to Llewyn next
The man walks down the block, whistles a cab, and climbs in. As it passes the mouth of the alley, Llewyn, sitting against the wall, touches two fingers to his forehead and says au revoir. It’s the last line of the Inside Llewyn Davis ending and the last line of the draft script, yet it is not goodbye. Au revoir means until we see each other again. Read it as resignation, as a joke at his own expense, or as the film telling you, in French, that the loop is about to run.
The case that it runs again
Everything the week has shown you, admittedly, points the same way. Jean says the same things will keep happening to him because he wants them to. Roland’s curse promises a life that never comes out right and a man who can’t remember making it that way. The six exits on the hub all close. So the next morning he will wake under a ceiling he doesn’t recognize, and it will be the Gorfeins’, and the day will start again.
The case that something changed
And yet. The second pass of the Inside Llewyn Davis ending isn’t identical, and the differences are all on Llewyn’s side. For one, he sang “Fare Thee Well” alone. He apologized to Lillian, cleanly, the night before. Ulysses came home, and on the last morning Llewyn kept the cat inside with his foot instead of losing it in the hall. Of course, none of this gets him a deal or a coat. The Coens are not in the business of handing out arcs. But a man who can finally sing the song is not quite the man who couldn’t, even if he’s sitting in the same slush.
“Dave Van Ronk didn’t fade out.”
Criterion commentary, over the closing credits
What the credits say
The film fades out on the alley, and the song over the credits is Dave Van Ronk’s own recording of “Green, Green Rocky Road,” the real voice after a week of versions. The commentary makes the point the film is too polite to: the movie ends with Dylan arriving, but Van Ronk didn’t fade out. Instead he kept working, kept teaching, and stayed the mayor of MacDougal Street for forty more years. The Coens’ joke in the making-of, about having more money for Llewyn Davis III, is a joke. The credits song, however, isn’t. It’s the film’s one hint that a life in the second tier is still a life.
Read: Dave Van Ronk versus Llewyn Davis, what the film borrowed and what it made up
Questions
The Inside Llewyn Davis ending: FAQ
The loop
Is the end of Inside Llewyn Davis the same as the beginning?
Yes. The Gaslight set and the alley beating that open the film are the same events that close it. The second time, the film adds a solo “Fare Thee Well,” the husband’s line about his wife, and the young singer taking the stage.
Does Inside Llewyn Davis take place in a time loop?
Not literally. The opening scene is the last night of the week shown out of order, so the film ends where it began. The Coens have called it a circle and an Odyssey in which the main character doesn’t go anywhere.
Why does Llewyn get beaten up at the end?
The man in the suit is the husband of Elizabeth Hobby, the singer from Arkansas Llewyn heckled off the Gaslight stage the night before. Afterward he came back to settle it. The second alley scene adds the line that explains it.
What does “au revoir” mean at the end of Inside Llewyn Davis?
Literally “until we see each other again.” Llewyn salutes the cab with it as the man leaves. It’s both a sardonic sign-off and a hint that the loop will run again.
The music
Is that Bob Dylan at the end of Inside Llewyn Davis?
In everything but name. The young singer plays “Farewell,” and the recording is a previously unreleased Dylan studio take presented as a live performance. Moreover, the draft script names him.
What song does Llewyn sing at the end?
“Hang Me, Oh Hang Me,” then “Fare Thee Well,” the song he recorded with his late partner Mike Timlin, sung alone for the first time.
What song plays over the credits of Inside Llewyn Davis?
Dave Van Ronk’s own recording of “Green, Green Rocky Road,” the song Llewyn plays in the car to Chicago.
Does Llewyn ever meet Bob Dylan?
No. He walks off the stage while the kid sits down and never looks at him. The scene is for the audience, who know what comes next.
Go deeper
More on Inside Llewyn Davis
Hub
The plot, the six offers Llewyn turns down, and why a good singer never gets anywhere.
Ulysses
The cat, the stray, and the Odyssey
Three cats, one name, and the journey home that only the animal completes.
Songs
What each song says about Llewyn
Every song in film order, how old it was in 1961, and what each choice does in the story.







