Deep SHT · Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)
Greenwich Village in 1961: The Real Folk Scene Behind Inside Llewyn Davis
The basket houses, the cabaret law, the Sunday riot, and the winter before everything changed.
When
February 1961, two months before the Washington Square riot
Where
MacDougal Street, Bleecker Street, and one living room uptown
Who ran it
Nobody. That was the point, until it wasn’t
$25
A Village apartment, give or take ten dollars
1 a.m.
When the bars closed and the coffee houses filled
3
Performers you could put on stage without a cabaret license
400k
Guitars sold in the United States by 1961
The moment before
What the Greenwich Village folk scene was in the winter of 1961
Elijah Wald, who co-wrote Dave Van Ronk’s memoir and consulted on the film, calls Greenwich Village in the 1961 winter of Inside Llewyn Davis the moment before. Nobody had long hair, nobody was writing songs, nobody was hoping to make a million dollars, and nobody thought they’d still be doing this at thirty. The biggest names on the Village folk scene in 1958 and 1959 were people even devoted fans don’t know now: Paul Clayton, Roy Berkeley, the Kossoy Sisters, who made one record and went off to get real jobs. Of the New Yorkers, only Van Ronk and the New Lost City Ramblers were still making music three years into the sixties.
What was already in motion
Even so, what was about to change had already started. A kid named Bob Dylan arrived in January 1961 looking for Woody Guthrie. The sit-ins had begun, and Peter, Paul and Mary were months from forming. Meanwhile, in September the New York Times would review an opening act at Gerde’s Folk City and the whole economy of the street would tilt. The film is set in the last winter when none of that had happened yet, and the Coens have said that’s the point: a scene on the edge of becoming an industry, photographed from the side that didn’t make it.
What this piece covers
This is the last of the Inside Llewyn Davis pages and the one about Greenwich Village in 1961 rather than the people in it. It covers the Sunday singing in Washington Square and the riot that followed two months after the film ends, the math of a basket house, the rooms on MacDougal Street one by one, the licensing law that made the whole thing possible, the labels, the one living room uptown, and what people who were there think the film got wrong. For the musicians, see who’s real and Dave Van Ronk.
Sundays
Washington Square Park, Sunday afternoons, and the riot
Before there were rooms, after all, there was the park. Since at least the forties, and by some accounts earlier, people had gathered in Washington Square on Sunday afternoons with guitars and banjos to sing. Eventually the city tried to shut it down, the singers got permits, and the permit ran from one to five. By the mid-fifties there were hundreds of guitars on a good Sunday. David Hajdu, on the Criterion commentary, tells the story of a Bleecker Street baker who claimed the sound carried so far it affected his bread. By 1961, however, the gathering was already on the wane and had a historical quality: people came to Washington Square because that was where people used to come.
The film puts Jean and Llewyn’s hardest conversation on a bench in that park, in daylight, in the cold, with no music anywhere. It’s a precise choice, therefore. The park is where the scene began, and the two of them sit in it arguing about abortion money and the suburbs.
April 9, 1961
Then, two months after the week the film covers, the city denied the Sunday permit. The parks commissioner, Newbold Morris, had decided folk singers drew the wrong element, and on Sunday, April 9, 1961, a few hundred of them showed up to sing anyway. Then the police moved in, and the confrontation was filmed by Dan Drasin, a teenager with a borrowed camera, and the short documentary he cut from it, Sunday, is on the Criterion disc. It is the sound of the scene in the film’s own year: a young man telling an officer that singing is an extension of speech, a woman explaining that the permit had been held for seventeen years without a problem, someone in the crowd saying real estate is at the bottom of this, and a cop saying, over and over, that the place to protest a denial is the permit office, not the park.
In the end the singers won. The permit was restored within weeks, and the fight became part of the scene’s origin story. Llewyn, who has no politics, never mentions it, and the film is careful not to. Still, the commentary points out that almost everyone around him would have been there, and that the civil rights movement, the sit-ins and the ban-the-bomb marches were bubbling through the same blocks that winter. The one character with a cause in the film is Len Chandler, who isn’t in it; Llewyn plays his song in the car.
The basket-house math
How a Village folk singer lived in 1961
Elijah Wald worked it out on the Criterion disc, and the numbers are the whole explanation for why the scene existed and why it couldn’t last.
One week, by the basket
Rooms you could play in one night, walking from one to the next
4 or 5
What the basket brought, on a good night
$25 to $30
A week of good nights
about $100
A Village apartment, per Wald’s best memory
$25 to $35
Nights of work to cover the rent
1
What the rest of the week was for
drinking money
Age at which anyone expected to still be doing this
30
Read the amber lines. In short, one night covered the rent, the rest was drinking money, and nobody expected to be doing it at thirty. Wald says this is the hardest thing for people to understand now: these people didn’t care about making a living, and the fact that they could make one playing the music they loved was a miracle. It worked, that is, as long as you were sleeping on couches. Llewyn is pushing thirty and sleeping on couches, and the math is about to stop working, which is a more exact description of his problem than anything anyone says to him in the film.
One night paid the rent. Nobody expected to be thirty.
The basket-house math, in one line
The rooms
MacDougal Street in 1961: the rooms, from the park to Gerde’s
Walk south from the park down MacDougal Street in the Greenwich Village of 1961 and you pass most of the scene in four blocks. Wald lays out the order the rooms opened in; the commentary adds what they were like inside.
Cafe Bizarre
First, the room built for folk music, opened by Rick Allmen in what had been Aaron Burr’s livery stable on West Third. It sold the idea that the Village was full of weirdos and you should come look: cobwebs on the walls, a doorman dressed as Frankenstein, waitresses dressed as Morticia, and folk singers, because folk singers were cheap and worked for tips. Evidently it worked.
Cafe Wha?
Next, a couple of doors down, opened by Manny Roth, the uncle of David Lee Roth. Fred Neil, who would write the theme to Midnight Cowboy, ran an afternoon hootenanny there, and that is where Dylan first turned up, playing harmonica behind Neil.
The Gaslight
Then, across the street: the Gaslight Poetry Cafe, a basement where Ginsberg and Corso had read, with no bar, coffee, maybe some Middle Eastern snacks, and a basket. By 1961 the poets were mostly gone to the East Village, although, as Van Ronk said, you kept one beat poet around for the look of the thing in case a tourist wanted to hear one. The film’s Gaslight is bigger than the real one and has an owner named Pappi, who is a composite of the Gaslight’s Sam Hood and Gerde’s Mike Porco. The 1962 footage above is the only film of the real room that anyone knows of.
Cafe Reggio
Still there on MacDougal, incidentally, which the commentary notes with some surprise. It’s where the film puts Llewyn and Jean’s careerist-and-loser exchange, and where Llewyn finds the stray outside the window.
The Folklore Center
Izzy Young’s shop on MacDougal, where records, instruments and gossip changed hands and where Dylan impressed Young early. Young knew the kid was putting him on, yet took him to every label in town anyway.
Gerde’s Folk City
Finally, around the corner on West Fourth, owned by Mike Porco, and significant, the commentary says, for being one of the first folk rooms with a bar. That, in turn, is why things happened there. It’s where Joel Coen’s founding image, a folk singer beaten in the alley behind the club, was set before the film moved it to the Gaslight, and it’s where the Times came in September.
A loophole
The cabaret law that built the Village folk scene
Coffee houses existed because of a loophole. New York’s cabaret licensing laws were intricate and expensive if you wanted a room with live music, but to spare the restaurants that already had string trios playing dinner, the law exempted any act of fewer than four people playing only string instruments: no horns, no woodwinds, no drums. Consequently a folk singer alone, or a duo, or a trio, needed no license at all. That is why the scene’s basic unit was one person on a stool with a guitar, and why the trio was the ceiling of ambition until Grossman built one that could sell records.
The second half of the loophole, meanwhile, was the clock. Bars had to close at one in the morning; the coffee houses didn’t. So the big business, Wald says, came after one, when the bars emptied the tourists onto the street and the coffee houses dragged them in, already drunk, for a cup of bad coffee. Van Ronk, for one, remembered them as the hardest audiences he ever worked. You had to keep them amused and then persuade them to put money in the basket, and he said the scene learned fast that sending a beautiful woman around politely got less than threatening them did.
The Italians and the bohos
One more thing the film gets from Greenwich Village in 1961. The South Village was an Italian neighborhood, and the commentary describes a real war between the Italians and the bohemians who had colonized their blocks. Pappi Corsicato, with his Nunzio and his bouncer Florio, is that war in one man: the local who owns the room, resents the people who fill it, and sleeps with their women. Mike Porco, the real owner of Gerde’s, was Calabrese, and the commentary thinks the character is really built on Joe Pesci. The who’s-real piece has the rest.
Money and ink
The labels, the Folklore Center, and the night the Times came
Three labels mattered to the scene, and accordingly the film has a version of each. Folkways, Moe Asch’s label, recorded the field recordings and the vernacular artists, signed the real Van Ronk, and paid almost nothing: a small advance, if that, and that was that. The film calls it Legacy and gives it to Mel Novikoff and his box of unsold records. Vanguard, Maynard Solomon’s label, signed Joan Baez. Columbia, by contrast, was the big label, the one with Doris Day and Mitch Miller, where a producer named John Hammond had the ears to hear something in a kid nobody else wanted. The film puts Llewyn in a Columbia studio for exactly one session, cutting a novelty single for cash.
The story of how the kid got there, moreover, runs through the Folklore Center. Izzy Young took Dylan to Folkways and to Vanguard and to everyone, and they all passed. Columbia signed him, and the commentary notes what that did to the rest of the street: people who had told themselves they were purists discovered they were jealous, which meant they had been ambitious all along. That is Jean and Llewyn’s argument in the park, a few months early.
September 26, 1961
Dylan opened for the Greenbriar Boys at Gerde’s Folk City that month, and Robert Shelton of the New York Times came down and wrote a review that was all about the opening act. It caught Hammond’s attention and, as a result, led to the Columbia deal. The commentary calls it a single moment in the origin myth of Bob Dylan, and notes that it wasn’t simple: Shelton was supposed to cover the folk scene generally, there are rumors he went down intending to prop Dylan up, and the Greenbriar Boys got a mention in the middle. The film knows all this. When Jean tells Llewyn that Pappi will let him play the Gaslight and the Times is going to be there, he says big deal. Seven months later, however, it was the biggest deal on the street, and he wasn’t on the bill.
Uptown
Uptown: the Gorfeins’ living room, the Village’s other address
The scene had a second home, although it wasn’t downtown. The Gorfeins live on the Upper West Side in what the commentary calls a quasi-bohemian, quasi-academic living room, and one of the critics, who was nine in 1961 and had a girlfriend on West 87th Street, says he sat in a million rooms like it: Columbia professors, folk records on the hi-fi, a guest who could be prodded into singing after dinner. Llewyn is their folk singer friend, the way other people had a painter. Likewise, it’s where he sleeps when the couches downtown run out.
The commentary also makes a point about the food. Lillian serves moussaka and says the word very deliberately, because moussaka was exotic in 1961, and the folk world had a patina of exoticism to it. The basket houses served espresso, not American coffee, and Middle Eastern snacks; they looked nothing like a nightclub or the Copacabana. You went to a small, dim room for mud-like coffee and something robustly American played by someone who looked like he hadn’t slept. The Gorfeins have brought that downstairs feeling up the subway line, and they want Llewyn to supply it on demand. His explosion at the table, then, is the scene’s whole class tension in one evening.
The record
What the film gets right, and what people who were there say
The rooms, the licensing, the money, the labels and the park of Greenwich Village in 1961 are all accurate, and the commentary’s critics, two of whom were in the Village in 1961, call the recreation pitch perfect. What the film compresses, instead, is time. Wald points out that the music you hear is really 1962 or 1963: Jim, Jean and Troy are already doing a Peter, Paul and Mary sound, and Paxton is singing a song he hadn’t written yet. The beatniks’ moment was 1959 and 1960; by the winter of the film they were a tourist attraction, buses coming in from the suburbs to see what the commentary remembers people calling Beatnikland. The Coens let a little of 1963 bleed into 1961 because the point is the moment before, not the calendar.
The dissent
Nevertheless, some people who lived it didn’t recognize it. Terri Thal, Van Ronk’s ex-wife and sometime manager, wrote that she didn’t expect the film to be almost unrecognizable as the folk world of the early sixties. Suzanne Vega said the Coens had taken a vibrant, competitive, communal, drunken, brawling scene and crumpled it into a slow brown sad movie. The critics on the commentary answer that the film isn’t a portrait of the scene at all; it’s a dark film about Bohemia, told from the side that lost, and the Coens have been clear that success stories had already been done. Both can be true, of course. Greenwich Village in 1961 was warmer than the film, and the film is about the one man in it who couldn’t feel the heat.
The shoot
Finally, two production facts belong here. The film was shot in New York in early 2012, and an early spring kept interfering with the bleak winter the Coens wanted, which is why so much of the slush looks like it was fought for. And after a chance meeting with a cab driver who lived at their old address, the Coens shot in the apartment they had rented themselves decades earlier. So the Village they rebuilt was, in one small way, the one they had lived in.
It’s our God-given right to sing.
A singer to a police officer, Washington Square Park, April 9, 1961
Questions
Greenwich Village in 1961: FAQ
The place
Was the Gaslight Cafe a real place?
Yes. The Gaslight Poetry Cafe was a MacDougal Street basement with no bar, where performers were paid from a basket. It began as a beat poetry room and became a folk room by the early sixties. The only known footage of it is from a 1962 film called Greenwich Village Story.
What was a basket house?
A coffee house that didn’t pay performers. A basket was passed through the audience and the acts split what came back. The format existed, specifically, because New York’s cabaret law exempted small string acts from licensing, so a folk singer on a stool was the cheapest legal entertainment in town.
What happened in Washington Square Park in 1961?
On April 9, 1961, two months after the week the film covers, the city denied the Sunday folk-singing permit and police confronted the singers who came anyway. Dan Drasin filmed it; his short documentary Sunday is on the Criterion disc. Afterward the permit was restored.
Was Gerde’s Folk City real?
Yes, on West Fourth Street, owned by Mike Porco. It was one of the first folk rooms with a bar, and the room where Robert Shelton of the New York Times reviewed a young Bob Dylan in September 1961.
The film
Is Inside Llewyn Davis accurate about Greenwich Village in 1961?
About the rooms, the money, the labels and the law, yes; the Criterion commentary calls the recreation pitch perfect. The music is a year or two ahead of its calendar, and some people who were there, including Dave Van Ronk’s ex-wife and Suzanne Vega, say the scene was warmer than the film shows.
Where was Inside Llewyn Davis filmed?
In New York City in early 2012, with an unseasonably early spring complicating the winter look. The Coens used the apartment they had rented themselves decades earlier after a chance meeting with a cab driver who lived there.
Why do the coffee houses in the film serve espresso and moussaka?
Because, simply, the real ones did. The commentary notes that the folk clubs offered espresso and Middle Eastern food, which were exotic in 1961 and part of the appeal: the rooms looked nothing like a nightclub.
How much did Village folk singers make in 1961?
Elijah Wald estimates $25 to $30 on a good night across four or five basket houses, roughly $100 a week, against rent of $25 to $35. Hence one good night paid the rent.
Go deeper
More on Inside Llewyn Davis
Hub
The plot, the six offers Llewyn turns down, and why a good singer never gets anywhere.
Who’s real
Grossman, Troy Nelson, and the Gate of Horn
The one character the Coens call real, and the models behind the rest.
Van Ronk
Dave Van Ronk versus Llewyn Davis
What the film kept of the Mayor of MacDougal Street, and what it cut.







