Coen Brothers

The Inside Llewyn Davis Screenplay vs. the Film

Bud Grossman asking Llewyn to play something from his album Inside Llewyn Davis

An early draft of the Inside Llewyn Davis screenplay has the whole structure in place: the loop, the cat, the curse, “au revoir,” and Bud Grossman’s audition down to “you’re not green.” What it doesn’t have is most of the music. The audition song is a blank, the father’s song is a different song, and the solo “Fare Thee Well” wasn’t on the page at all. Here’s what the Coens changed, where each change happened, and a beat sheet of the finished film.

Learn MoreThe Inside Llewyn Davis Screenplay vs. the Film

Inside Llewyn Davis Songs: Every Song and What It Says About Llewyn

Llewyn Davis singing Hang Me Oh Hang Me alone on the Gaslight Cafe stage in Inside Llewyn Davis

The songs in Inside Llewyn Davis say what Llewyn won’t. Line them up in the order the film plays them and count their age in the winter of 1961: his are 90, 53 and 400 years old; the hits around him are new, and a few hadn’t been written yet. This guide takes every song by what it does in the story, from the harmony Llewyn refuses to the hit he signs away for $200, and shows what the screenplay draft left blank.

Learn MoreInside Llewyn Davis Songs: Every Song and What It Says About Llewyn

Dave Van Ronk and Inside Llewyn Davis: What the Film Borrowed and What It Made Up

Dave Van Ronk in a tweed jacket with a cigarette, leaning in a Greenwich Village doorway, wide crop of the Inside Dave Van Ronk album cover photograph

The Coens have said it every time they’re asked: Llewyn Davis is not Dave Van Ronk. Yet the title, the cover, the songs and the arrangements are his, down to the fingerpicking. This piece sets the real man beside the character: the jazz snob who took up folk for the money, the Trotskyist with the couch half the Village slept on, the mentor who taught Bob Dylan “House of the Rising Sun” and lost it to him. What the film kept was everything Van Ronk had. What it cut was everything he was.

Learn MoreDave Van Ronk and Inside Llewyn Davis: What the Film Borrowed and What It Made Up

Who’s Real in Inside Llewyn Davis: Bud Grossman, Troy Nelson, and the Rest

Bud Grossman listening to Llewyn's audition at the Gate of Horn in Inside Llewyn Davis

Inside Llewyn Davis isn’t a true story, but it’s set in a real place at a real moment, with the people rearranged. This piece goes character by character: Albert Grossman and the Gate of Horn that was really much smaller, Tom Paxton hitching in from Fort Dix, Ramblin’ Jack Elliott’s cowboy costume, Moe Asch’s Folkways behind Mel Novikoff’s Legacy Records, the Clancy Brothers in their sweaters, and the one person the Coens could have named and didn’t. With performance footage of the real musicians beside the characters they became.

Learn MoreWho’s Real in Inside Llewyn Davis: Bud Grossman, Troy Nelson, and the Rest

Greenwich Village in 1961: The Real Folk Scene Behind Inside Llewyn Davis

Wide shot of Llewyn Davis mid-song during Hang Me Oh Hang Me at the Gaslight in Inside Llewyn Davis

Inside Llewyn Davis is set in February 1961, two months before the police shut down Sunday singing in Washington Square and the Village fought back. This is the scene the film was built from: the coffee houses that existed because of a licensing loophole, the basket that paid the rent in one good night, the rooms on MacDougal Street one by one, the labels, the Times review that changed everything, and what people who were there say the Coens got wrong.

Learn MoreGreenwich Village in 1961: The Real Folk Scene Behind Inside Llewyn Davis

No Country for Old Men Meaning: The Three Mirrors the Coens Added

Sheriff Ed Tom Bell's hatted silhouette reflected in the glass of a switched-off television in Moss's trailer in No Country for Old Men

Three times the Coens hand Anton Chigurh a line, a seat or a reflection, then give the same thing to one of the men hunting him. Moss whispers the killer’s “hold still” at an antelope. Bell drinks his milk on the same sofa and finds his own hat in the dead TV screen. At the motel the one mirror that reflects the sheriff is turned so only the killer can look. The screenplay, held against the novel and the film, shows which of these McCarthy wrote and which the Coens added, and what the pattern says about what the film means.

Learn MoreNo Country for Old Men Meaning: The Three Mirrors the Coens Added

No Country for Old Men Screenplay Beat Sheet: Page vs Minute

no country for old men screenplay Anton Chigurh strangles sheriff's deputy opening scene

The No Country for Old Men story isn't hard to follow — it just refuses to give you what you expect. Llewelyn Moss finds two million dollars in the Texas desert and takes it, Anton Chigurh is sent to get it back, and Sheriff Bell follows the bodies trying to reach Moss first. What happens next is where the film breaks every genre rule it has carefully established: Moss dies off-screen, Chigurh walks away, and Bell retires to his breakfast table to describe a dream. This is a complete breakdown of what actually happens, and why every structural choice is deliberate.

Learn MoreNo Country for Old Men Screenplay Beat Sheet: Page vs Minute

The Cat in Inside Llewyn Davis: Ulysses, the Stray, and the Odyssey

The Gorfeins' cat watching the subway tunnel through the train window in Inside Llewyn Davis

The Coens added the cat to give a plotless week a spine. It became the film’s clearest mirror: “Llewyn is the cat,” as the receptionist says, and the animal named Ulysses completes the journey home that Llewyn never does. This piece counts the cats, traces each one’s route, follows the stray into Roland Turner’s car, and reads the Odyssey parallels scene by scene, from the dog Argos to Poseidon’s curse.

Learn MoreThe Cat in Inside Llewyn Davis: Ulysses, the Stray, and the Odyssey